The State of Arizona has recently
endured an embarrassing episode where the legislature passed an amendment to
the state’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act
allowing business owners to deny service to gay and lesbian customers so long
as proprietors were acting solely on their religious beliefs. This caused such a national outcry and
threats of boycotting Arizona (moving the Superbowl from there next year!!!)
that even legislators who’d voted for the bill were startled by what might
happen and urged Governor Jan Brewer to veto it, which she promptly did. The dustup over this caused the withdrawal of
similar bills in other states, including Ohio where I live. Whew!
So consider this
question. If you’re a baker in a town in
Arizona and your religious beliefs cause you to abhor homosexuals, and then a
gay couple asks you to bake them a wedding cake and you refuse, does this
obvious discrimination now expose you to a lawsuit?
No. It doesn’t.
Residents of Arizona (except Phoenix, which has a municipal ordinance
protecting gays from discrimination in employment, housing, and public
accommodations) are perfectly free to be as homophobic as they like in refusing
to hire or retain gay employees, rent them rooms or sell them houses, and deal
with them in public businesses like a bakery.
There is neither an Arizona statute nor federal law that gives gay
people any protection at all in these matters.
What? If that’s the case, why did the Arizona
legislature feel it was necessary to pass the homophobic bill in the first
place? Apparently the legislators were
frightened by lawsuits in other states (Oregon, Colorado) where bakers (and
retailers in similar situations) were successfully sued by gays who were turned
away at the bakery door. And it’s true
that the Arizona statute would have voided the part of the Phoenix ordinance
dealing with discrimination as to public accommodation. Both Oregon and Colorado do have state laws protecting gays from this sort of discrimination, hence the successful lawsuits there.
But, really, isn’t there
some federal law being violated by discrimination against gays? No, and so far Barack Obama has refused to issue an executive order in hiring matters to protect gay federal employees.
For years Congress has made attempts to pass the Employment
Non-Discrimination Act [“ENDA”] which would add anti-gay discrimination in
hiring (but not housing or public accommodations) to the Civil Rights Laws. It has always failed to clear prior
Congresses, but the current Senate did manage to vote for the bill (with
admirable bi-partisan support, including Republican Senators like John
McCain). Alas, the bill stands no
change of passage in the Republican-controlled House of Representative.
Senator Ted Cruz (R. Texas)
has recently introduced a bill in the Senate which would allow states to refuse
to recognize marriages validly entered into by gay couples in other states (it
is co-sponsored by Senator Mike Lee (R. Utah)).
The bill has no chance of even being voted on in the
Democratically-controlled Senate, and, in any event, would be vetoed by
President Obama. But Cruz says that his “heart
weeps” over the progress that gays are making, and his anti-gay activities make
him the darling of the Tea Party just as the 2016 Presidential campaign begins
Twenty states and the
District of Columbia have enacted laws prohibiting discrimination against gay
people (some of which also protect transgendered individuals), and many
municipalities have ordinances doing the same.
Below is a chart on point that the ACBL has created; for a
clickable-version see //www.aclu.org/maps/non-discrimination-laws-state-state-information-map.
let me note that, as I’ve said before, I’m very sure that gay marriage itself
will be completely legal in all states by 2016 when the United States Supreme
Court takes the happy step of using the 14th Amendment to grant
equal protection to gays who love each other and decide to claim the legal
status that marriage bestows in so many ways.
“Boycott ‘Ender’s Game’?
Orson Scott Card and Profiting From Homophobia,” September 20, 2013
“Disowning Your Gay Children,” October 9, 2013
"Falling in Love, Turning 70, and Getting Married," October 21, 2013
“Republican Politicians: Reluctant Homophobes?” November 26, 2013
“Gays Will Be Able To Marry in All States By July of 2016 (and Maybe
2015): A Prediction,” February 14, 2014
"Gay Marriage, The 6th Circuit, Jeffrey Sutton, and the Supreme Court," November 13, 2014
"Alan Turing: Torturing a Gay Genius to Death," November 26, 2014;
“A Gay Hoosier Lawyer Looks at Indiana’s RFRA:
The Religious Bigot Protection Act,” March 30, 2015; http://douglaswhaley.blogspot.com/2015/03/a-gay-hoosier-lawyer-looks-at-indianas.html
"A Guide to the Best of My Blog," April 29, 2013
Post a Comment